| Date | Opponent | Time |
| Sept. 1 | Thomas More (Ky.) - game info | 40-24 Loss |
| Sept. 8 | Butler | 44-14 Loss |
| Sept. 15 | at Washington & Jefferson (Pa.) | 50-14 Loss |
| Sept. 29 | at Rose-Hulman* | 24-7 Loss |
| Oct. 6 | at Mount St. Joseph (Ohio)* | 56-21 Loss |
| Oct. 13 | Manchester* (Homecoming) | 30-28 Win |
| Oct. 20 | at Defiance (Ohio)* | 33-7 Loss |
| Oct. 27 | Bluffton (Ohio)* | 24-21 Win |
| Nov. 3 | at Anderson* | 37-27 Loss |
| Nov. 10 | Franklin* (Senior Day) | 55-14 Loss |